PROJECTS FEEDBACK

Any participant in the INSPIRELI AWARDS competition can ask a member of the international jury for feedback on his/her competition project. Jurors are assigned across continents at a ratio of one juror per student. The resulting gallery is a unique architecture textbook, created free of charge by those who wish to participate in our project and contribute their work to the education of the up and coming generation. We are honored that you are sharing your designs and experiences here.

187 Results

Apartment projects feedbacks

The approach, which includes interdisciplinarity and the relationship of subjective, personal, and neutral perceptions of the problem and characteristics of the area in general, gave added value to the project. The main (general) project aim is good and connected with its application to the port area through urban planning and design principles. A particular contribution of the work is the extensive analysis of local culture, lifestyle, and needs of local citizens, which were the basis for…

Mirjana Barać

advisor
Mirjana Barać

Interesting work on the organization of a public space for communication between people with the color of natural cultures and the coverage of departments of materials in architecture. But, be that as it may, the presentation in popular authors. 1 Clearer floor plans. (blurry, difficult to read plans) With the name of the premises and functional zoning. the availability of possibly accessible questions for people with limited tastes. 2 No master plan. Or a situational scheme with orientation…

Maxim Artamonov

advisor
Maxim Artamonov

Hi Carolina its been an Honor to review your project..... :) this is a beautiful project and make me do some initial research about the site. this is my comment: 1. The Silos Memorial development should be parallel with the bussiness district development. The bussiness district should be initiated on the first place because it can be an attractor to both Marina and residential area. It can also escalate the land price and the value of the area and give a significant impact on taxes revenue…

Adli Nadia

advisor
Adli Nadia

It is good to see another zahahadidesque way of creating shapes. I personally liked this approach to urban grid - lively and irregular. Overall impession is also convinient (if we leave unnoticed out-of-scale kiter on the foreground, of course). The area surrounding the silo is also well designed but the amount of eathwork needed is huge - that is the main question of this project for me. Speaking of the silo - I'm asking myself - yes this is a renmant of the tragedy - but do we really need to…

Alexander Grebennikov

advisor
Alexander Grebennikov

Good afternoon, Vladimir! I really liked your project! The first thing that attracts attention when viewing is a good presentation. Although it might be worth making some visualizations more realistic. I am pleased with the fullness of the project, I feel the deep elaboration of the idea. It seems to me that you have found interesting architectural solutions that have allowed you to connect different functional blocks, as well as keep in touch with the environment. Great! I wish you further…

Olga Malykh

advisor
Olga Malykh

Interesting proposal to cover large areas and functional needs. Its great advantage is that it can fit any location, any size anywhere in the world. at the same time, it is also a pain point for me it does not seem to have any local quality . As for layout options, It is important to set a limit to building height, and structural stability would have to be solved. The number of modul types shown on the panel are way too many, i feel. utting the modul types down to 4-6 would probably result in…

Simon Viktória

advisor
Simon Viktória

The representation of the project is quite satisfactory. Well done. The high-rise buildings on the waterfront are disturbing in the morphology of the city. The design of this area blocks the visual connection of the city with the sea, and the grouping of the buildings is closely related. In the urban context, the bridge that will carry people to the port seems to complicate the work. This issue could have been easily resolved. It occupies too much of the residential area on three separate…

Nazan KIRCI

advisor
Nazan KIRCI

The concept is interesting, but it leaves the reader with some unanswered questions. Since an upright cube is more stable than a tilted one what makes it a stable house? What makes it unique in its stability? And what is the story behind it? Regarding functionality, the door from the living room to the outdoor space through the sliding partition seems hardly accessible because of the inclined door threshold as shown in the section. The outdoor stair seems like an interesting concept but the…

Majd Abu-Ajamieh

advisor
Majd Abu-Ajamieh

Dear Alexandra, One challenge that always presents itself in this type of project is one of community connections. You have done a great job of managing to achieve a sense of community in your general planning between buildings. Additionally, this layout has allowed each building to have a sense of privacy by being well spaced apart from each other. Connecting the building with common public spaces and commercial spaces is also very thoughtful and allows people to connect with each other. Well…

Pierre Tatem

advisor
Pierre Tatem

Copyright © 2022 INSPIRELI | All rights reserved. Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and use of cookies.