PROJECTS FEEDBACK

The project is well conceptualized within 'sustainable' development and the attempts to save the environment are praiseworthy. The ideas of re-using old boats and not exploiting the lands physically too much are excellent. Living in boats is not uncommon in many parts of the world. The way a holiday resort is conceptualized as villas within boats on a site adjacent to the shore is hence nicely perceived. I want to congratulate the students for even imagining in such a way in today's time when…

Read more...

Shafinaz Sameen

advisor

Just a thought, why everything is so mundane-looking structure when the site seems to be so promising? Should break the boundaries & think out of the box. Also, think of accessible spaces for physically challenged people. Microlevel thinking is required, and basic macro-level planning is good.

Read more...

Ankita Sweety

advisor

Hello Ana, and congratulations on your submission. It is a large-scale project with a high level of complexity, primarily due to its complicated site conditions. Open views seem to be an essential component of the design approach; I wonder why choosing an introverted typology for the villas. Maybe pools could work better if placed in front of the villas? Also, does a very valuable frontage near the water look too solid? Maybe there was a way to increase functional porosity by adding some F&B…

Read more...

Cristiano Luchetti

advisor

المشروع جريء لكنه يحتاج دراسة البعد الأمني والخصوصيه للدراسين والمبتكريين وكذا فصل الحركه الاليه مثل السيارات عن المبني ودراسة البعد الانساني في الخدمات داخل المبني. الشكل الإنشائي جيد لكن يحتاج دراسة العلاقه بين الكتل المصمته والفراغات

Read more...

Osman Mahmoud Osman

advisor

توفير ممرات للرياضه داخل بيئة صحيه محاطه بالاشجار للمسنين الممرات اخري للشباب ويضاف مقاعد للجلوس بالحدائق المتاحه داخل هذا النموذج الجيد

Read more...

Osman Mahmoud Osman

advisor

Dear students, you aim to combine offers of insight into the beauty of location and its natural environment to the public by visiting. I recommend that you enhance project idea and spatio-technical concepts by - Avoiding any competition between technical media/ screens/ films/ light and the pure beauty of nature itself, - Protecting ground conditions, fauna and flora from stepping into them and dstroying valuable parts of them by elevated wooden path systems which allow observation from "above"…

Read more...

Andrea Haase

advisor

Hello Prakriti, Siyang, Shuyao and Sonali, The images of your project evidence your work and order in the design process. I appreciate the visual aid and the level of graphic representation you presented. Urban design and the city itself is a topic that requires multiple disciplines of study. It is really cool to see how you introduce technology to maximize the potential of strategies to help human beings and the environment.  Following, I address some points that you can try to apply in your…

Read more...

Jose Carlo Bolaños Padilla

advisor

Research. Great job on the research and the context! Masterplan. The centre of your plot is occupied with parking, and the public park is disconnected from the rest of the buildings. In my opinion, putting cars above residents' needs is a wrong priority. The same is for the playground. Plans. Great ideas on organizing the space, but for my taste, bathrooms and bedrooms are too small. You cannot place the shower or a bath inside the bathroom (washroom), and you cannot place even a wardrobe…

Read more...

Andrii Shtendera

advisor

In my opinion your design is very good, but there are several drawings that must be completed, such as on the floor plan dimensions must be added, building pieces must be sized, the concept must be added to the drawings and explanations, architectural details and structural details must be added.

Read more...

Uzhma Abdul Halim

advisor